Best Teething Toys — 2026 Reviews

• Made from 100% natural rubber — free of BPA, PVC, phthalates
• Soft squeaking sound stimulates auditory development
• Multiple textures on body, legs, head and ears for different oral areas
• Expensive for a teether at ~$25

“The most gifted teether in the world for good reason. Natural rubber, age-appropriate design, multiple textures, and 60 years of safety history make Sophie the benchmark against which all other teethers are measured.”

• Dual function: teether + oral hygiene training toothbrush
• Banana shape is developmentally intuitive for self-directed mouthing
• Soft silicone bristles are gentle on emerging teeth and gums
• Bristles require replacement at 3 months (separate brush needed)

“The only teether that simultaneously introduces oral hygiene habits. The bristle texture provides gum relief while familiarizing baby with the brushing sensation — making the toothbrushing transition at 12 months significantly easier.”

• Looped tube design provides multiple gripping handles for small hands
• Gentle rattle for auditory stimulation
• Soft BPA-free plastic loops are easy to grasp
• Smooth surface only — no varied texture compared to Sophie

“One of the best first toys and teethers for newborns. The multiple loop handles are uniquely accessible to infants still developing grip, and the gentle rattle provides auditory feedback for cause-and-effect learning.”

• Refrigerator-safe — cold therapy for inflamed gums
• Alternating hard and soft surfaces on every key
• Ring design easy for small hands to hold
• Not freezer-safe — freezer temperatures can harden excessively

“The best-value refrigerator teether. Cold therapy is the most effective non-medication teething pain relief, and the $5 price makes this a standard registry item for every teething kit.”

• Ultra-soft silicone — mimics the feel of natural skin
• 100% food-grade silicone with no chemicals
• Squeezable body — babies can manipulate and deform it
• No varied texture — single-surface soft silicone only

“The best silicone teether for babies who prefer very soft surfaces. The skin-like silicone texture is uniquely soothing for babies going through aggressive teething who want ultra-gentle contact.”

• Finger-worn design — baby cannot drop it
• Raspberry bumps cover entire surface for all-around gum coverage
• 100% food-grade silicone
• Elastic loop can be outgrown quickly on larger-handed babies

“The best hands-free teether. The finger-worn design solves the most frustrating aspect of teething toys: babies dropping them immediately. Once on the hand, it stays accessible all day.”

• Multiple textures target different gum zones
• Flexible enough to flex under biting pressure
• BPA-free materials throughout
• Simpler design than premium teethers

“A reliable everyday teether from a trusted baby brand. The multiple textures and affordable price make it a practical add-on to any teething kit.”